Tithing comparisons between the Catholic and the Mormon Church

Tithing is mandated by the LDS Church -- but is not mandated by the Catholic Church

The Catholic Church tells us tithing is voluntary ... perhaps about 1/40th of your wage ... or about 2.5 percent. And, then, this is according to your ability to pay. There is no commandment or "law."

In contrast, tithing IS a law and mandated commandment for the LDS, Mormon Church member. He must pay 10% of his GROSS income regardless of income level or ability to pay. Failure to pay this payment means denial of status, entrance to the Mormon Temple, a good celestial life, salvation, and other blessings.

The law of tithing is frequently enforced by frequent private interviews with your bishop and stake president (minister). You can't be issued a temple recommend unless you state that you pay an honest full tithing.

Unfortunately, in addition to this 10% tithing, LDS members donate "fast offerings" and many other donations. One of these, above and beyond the tithe, is the financing of your children on Mormon missions. This can be a devastating and crippling expense for low or mid-income families since missions are also mandated and commanded by the church. Families are expected to foot the hefty bill for these missions. Mormonism, then, is a very expensive religion to join.

There is no commanded tithing in the Catholic Religion. You are expected to pay a tithe of only what you can afford .... a much more realistic approach to tithing. Besides that, Catholic tithing donations go toward paying their ministers. (Mormon ministers receive no pay -- only the very top hierarchy receive pay -- some with fat salaries and perks)

The following article was written to the Catholic members to explain tithing in the Catholic Church:

Catholicism Straight Answers: Are We Required to Tithe?

By Fr. William Saunders HERALD Columnist

Although we may not have a rule of tithing, we do have the duty to support the needs of the Church, whether at the international, diocesan or parish level. Each of us should evaluate what we do "give back to God" through our support of the Church and charitable organization.

For example, we should ask, "Do I give to God each week at least what I spend on entertainment, such as movies? Do I give to God at least one hour's worth of my 40 hour pay check?"

Fr. Saunders is pastor of Queen of Apostles Church in Alexandria.

Page Modified March 8, 2007

Back to Home Page